Association between Kidney Donor Profile Index (KDPI) and Kidney Transplant Outcomes in Non-US Cohorts:A Systematic Review
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.61882/ijkd.20.5.9473Keywords:
End-Stage kidney disease, Kidney donor profile index, Kidney transplantation, Graft survival, Delayed graft function, Transplant outcomes, Systematic reviewAbstract
Introduction. End-stage kidney disease is a global health issue. While prediction models like the Kidney Donor Profile Index (KDPI) assess donor quality, the published evidence on its performance is heterogenous. This study aimed to systematically review the association between KDPI and transplant outcomes to optimize clinical decisions and allocation strategies.
Methods. We searched PubMed, Scopus, and Web of Science for studies up to December 2024. We included studies on adult kidney transplant recipients that reported KDPI values and compared them with transplant outcomes. The review question was structured according to PICO: population, adult kidney transplant recipients; exposure, KDPI; comparator, lower KDPI categories or lower donor-risk strata; and outcomes, graft survival, patient survival, delayed graft function (DGF), and kidney function. Studies were assessed for quality using the Newcastle-Ottawa Scale. Exclusion criteria involved non-human, pediatric studies, and research without specific transplant outcomes. A grey literature search via Google Scholar, as well as backward and forward citation searching were performed.
Results. Overall, 10 studies met the inclusion criteria. These studies included 15,879 participants and were conducted across several countries, mostly in Germany. Higher KDPI values were associated with poorer graft survival, reduced kidney function, and an increased incidence of DGF. However, the relationship between KDPI and patient survival was less clear, with some studies reporting no significant association.
Conclusions. Higher KDPI values were associated with poorer graft survival, increased risk of DGF, and reduced kidney function post-transplant. Further studies should explore its interaction with recipient factors and long-term outcomes.
Downloads
References
1. Gupta R, Woo K, Yi JA. Epidemiology of end-stage kidney disease. Seminars in Vascular Surgery. 2021;34(1):71-8.
2. Thurlow JS, Joshi M, Yan G, Norris KC, Agodoa LY, Yuan CM, et al. Global Epidemiology of End-Stage Kidney Disease and Disparities in Kidney Replacement Therapy. American Journal of Nephrology. 2021;52(2):98-107.
3. Azegami T, Kounoue N, Sofue T, Yazawa M, Tsujita M, Masutani K, et al. Efficacy of pre-emptive kidney transplantation for adults with end-stage kidney disease: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Renal Failure. 2023;45(1):2169618.
4. Rao PS, Schaubel DE, Guidinger MK, Andreoni KA, Wolfe RA, Merion RM, et al. A comprehensive risk quantification score for deceased donor kidneys: the kidney donor risk index. Transplantation. 2009;88(2):231-6.
5. Munivenkatappa RB, Schweitzer EJ, Papadimitriou JC, Drachenberg CB, Thom KA, Perencevich EN, et al. The Maryland aggregate pathology index: a deceased donor kidney biopsy scoring system for predicting graft failure. Am J Transplant. 2008;8(11):2316-24.
6. Massie AB, Leanza J, Fahmy LM, Chow EKH, Desai NM, Luo X, et al. A risk index for living donor kidney transplantation. American journal of transplantation. 2016;16(7):2077-84.
7. Querard AH, Le Borgne F, Dion A, Giral M, Mourad G, Garrigue V, et al. Propensity score-based comparison of the graft failure risk between kidney transplant recipients of standard and expanded criteria donor grafts: Toward increasing the pool of marginal donors. Am J Transplant. 2018;18(5):1151-7.
8. Rege A, Irish B, Castleberry A, Vikraman D, Sanoff S, Ravindra K, et al. Trends in Usage and Outcomes for Expanded Criteria Donor Kidney Transplantation in the United States Characterized by Kidney Donor Profile Index. Cureus. 2016;8(11):e887.
9. Page MJ, McKenzie JE, Bossuyt PM, Boutron I, Hoffmann TC, Mulrow CD, et al. The PRISMA 2020 statement: an updated guideline for reporting systematic reviews. International journal of surgery. 2021;88:105906.
10. Haddaway NR, Collins AM, Coughlin D, Kirk S. The role of Google Scholar in evidence reviews and its applicability to grey literature searching. PloS one. 2015;10(9):e0138237.
11. Del Moral Martín RMG, Retamero Díaz JA, Cava Molina M, Cobacho Tornel BM, Bravo Soto J, Osuna Ortega A, et al. Validation of KDRI/KDPI for the selection of expanded criteria kidney donors. Nefrologia (Engl Ed). 2018;38(3):297-303.
12. Zens TJ, Danobeitia JS, Leverson G, Chlebeck PJ, Zitur LJ, Redfield RR, et al. The impact of kidney donor profile index on delayed graft function and transplant outcomes: A single-center analysis. Clin Transplant. 2018;32(3):e13190.
13. Arias-Cabrales CE, Pérez-Sáez MJ, Redondo-Pachón D, Buxeda A, Burballa C, Duran X, et al. Relevance of KDPI value and acute rejection on kidney transplant outcomes in recipients with delayed graft function - a retrospective study. Transpl Int. 2020;33(9):1071-7.
14. Park WY, Kim JH, Ko EJ, Min JW, Ban TH, Yoon HE, et al. Impact of Kidney Donor Profile Index Scores on Post-Transplant Clinical Outcomes Between Elderly and Young Recipients, A Multicenter Cohort Study. Sci Rep. 2020;10(1):7009.
15. Villanego F, Vigara LA, Cazorla JM, Naranjo J, Atienza L, Garcia AM, et al. Evaluation of Expanded Criteria Donors Using the Kidney Donor Profile Index and the Preimplantation Renal Biopsy. Transpl Int. 2022;35:10056.
16. Prunster J, Wong G, Larkins N, Wyburn K, Francis R, Mulley WR, et al. Kidney Donor Profile Index and allograft outcomes: interactive effects of estimated post-transplant survival score and ischaemic time. Clin Kidney J. 2023;16(3):473-83.
17. Sexton DJ, O'Kelly P, Kennedy C, Denton M, de Freitas DG, Magee C, et al. Assessing the discrimination of the Kidney Donor Risk Index/Kidney Donor Profile Index scores for allograft failure and estimated glomerular filtration rate in Ireland's National Kidney Transplant Programme. Clin Kidney J. 2019;12(4):569-73.
18. Kim JH, Lee SH, Kim JS, Hwang HS, Ko H, Jung CW, et al. Clinical significance of the living kidney donor profile index for predicting long-term posttransplant outcomes: results from the Korean Organ Transplantation Registry. Kidney Res Clin Pract. 2023.
19. Calvillo-Arbizu J, Pérez-Valdivia MA, Gentil-Govantes MA, Castro-de-la-Nuez P, Mazuecos-Blanca A, Rodríguez-Benot A, et al. Does the Kidney Donor Profile Index (KDPI) predict graft and patient survival in a Spanish population? Nefrologia (Engl Ed). 2018;38(6):587-95.
20. Lee JH, Park WY, Kim YS, Choi BS, Park CW, Yang CW, et al. Clinical significance of the Kidney Donor Profile Index in deceased donors for prediction of post-transplant clinical outcomes: A multicenter cohort study. PLoS One. 2018;13(10):e0205011.
21. Lehner LJ, Kleinsteuber A, Halleck F, Khadzhynov D, Schrezenmeier E, Duerr M, et al. Assessment of the Kidney Donor Profile Index in a European cohort. Nephrol Dial Transplant. 2018;33(8):1465-72.
22. Dahmen M, Becker F, Pavenstädt H, Suwelack B, Schütte-Nütgen K, Reuter S. Validation of the Kidney Donor Profile Index (KDPI) to assess a deceased donor's kidneys' outcome in a European cohort. Sci Rep. 2019;9(1):11234.
23. Bisigniano L, Tagliafichi V, Antik A. Validation of the Kidney Donor Profile Index in Argentina. Transplant Proc. 2020;52(4):1049-52.
24. García-Covarrubias A, Morales J, Espinosa V, Rodríguez MDP, Torres A, Zalazar A, et al. Kidney Donor Profile Index in a Transplant Center in Mexico. Transplant Proc. 2020;52(4):1136-9.
25. Prado NP, Silva CKD, Meinerz G, Kist R, Garcia VD, Keitel E. Usefulness of Kidney Donor Profile Index (KDPI) to predict graft survival in a South Brazilian Cohort. J Bras Nefrol. 2020;42(2):211-8.
26. Bachmann Q, Haberfellner F, Büttner-Herold M, Torrez C, Haller B, Assfalg V, et al. The Kidney Donor Profile Index (KDPI) Correlates With Histopathologic Findings in Post-reperfusion Baseline Biopsies and Predicts Kidney Transplant Outcome. Front Med (Lausanne). 2022;9:875206.
27. Darema M, Athanasopoulou D, Bellos I, Tsoumbou I, Vittoraki AG, Bokos J, et al. Evaluation of Kidney Donor Risk Index/Kidney Donor Profile Index as Predictor Tools of Deceased-Donor Kidney Transplant Outcomes in a Greek Cohort. J Clin Med. 2023;12(6).
28. Foresto RD, Hazin MAA, Cassão BC, de Morais APA, Felipe CR, Requião-Moura LR, et al. The Association Between Kidney Donor Profile Index and 1-y Graft Function. Transplant Direct. 2023;9(5):e1476.
29. Klein KB, Stafinski TD, Menon D. Predicting Survival after Liver Transplantation Based on Pre-Transplant MELD Score: a Systematic Review of the Literature. PLOS ONE. 2013;8(12):e80661.
30. Riley S, Zhang Q, Tse W-Y, Connor A, Wei Y. Using Information Available at the Time of Donor Offer to Predict Kidney Transplant Survival Outcomes: A Systematic Review of Prediction Models. Transplant International. 2022;35.
31. Bellini MI, Nozdrin M, Pengel L, Knight S, Papalois V. How good is a living donor? Systematic review and meta-analysis of the effect of donor demographics on post kidney transplant outcomes. Journal of Nephrology. 2022;35(3):807-20.
32. Teixeira AC, Freire de Carvalho CC, Mororó GP, Pereira LDM, Lacerda VS, Esmeraldo RM. Evaluation of Frozen and Paraffin Sections Using the Maryland Aggregate Pathology Index Score in Donor Kidney Biopsy Specimens of a Brazilian Cohort. Transplantation Proceedings. 2017;49(10):2247-50.
33. Wang CJ, Wetmore JB, Crary GS, Kasiske BL. The Donor Kidney Biopsy and Its Implications in Predicting Graft Outcomes: A Systematic Review. American Journal of Transplantation. 2015;15(7):1903-14.
34. von Moos S, Akalin E, Mas V, Mueller TF. Assessment of Organ Quality in Kidney Transplantation by Molecular Analysis and Why It May Not Have Been Achieved, Yet. Frontiers in Immunology. 2020;11.
35. Gomes VM, dos Santos LI, de Carvalho Silva BDP, Fabreti-Oliveira RA. Impact of donor expanded criteria kidney transplantation on clinical outcomes and survival: A single-center experience. Transplant Immunology. 2024;86:102116.
36. Ma MKM, Lim WH, Craig JC, Russ GR, Chapman JR, Wong G. Mortality among Younger and Older Recipients of Kidney Transplants from Expanded Criteria Donors Compared with Standard Criteria Donors. Clinical Journal of the American Society of Nephrology. 2016;11(1).
37. Pascual J, Zamora J, Pirsch JD. A Systematic Review of Kidney Transplantation From Expanded Criteria Donors. American Journal of Kidney Diseases. 2008;52(3):553-86.
38. Kaboré R, Haller MC, Harambat J, Heinze G, Leffondré K. Risk prediction models for graft failure in kidney transplantation: a systematic review. Nephrology Dialysis Transplantation. 2017;32(suppl_2):ii68-ii76.
Downloads
Published
Data Availability Statement
The data that supports the findings of this study are available in the supplementary material of this article.